BEYOND THE EPISODE · FOOD & CULTURE
Who Gets to
Be Dinner?
Why a provocative French book asks us to reconsider the animals we love, the animals we eat, and the invisible rules separating them.
“I don't love animals. I simply respect them.”
Aymeric Caron, Antispéciste (2016) · translated from French
It is an unexpected opening for a book about animal rights. But when French journalist and television personality Aymeric Caron published Antispéciste in 2016, he was not asking his readers to become animal lovers. He was asking them to become more consistent.
Consider two animals: a dog and a pig. Both are capable of feeling pain, experiencing fear and displaying remarkable intelligence. Yet in much of Western society, one sleeps on our sofa while the other ends up on our dinner plate. Why?
The answer, Caron argues, lies in something called speciesism: the belief that belonging to a particular species is enough to justify treating its interests as less important than those of another. The idea was not new. Philosophers and animal rights campaigners had been discussing speciesism since the 1970s. But Caron brought it into mainstream French cultural debate, in a country where food is deeply connected to national identity, tradition and pleasure.
His argument goes considerably further than asking people to eat less meat. He questions whether humans have the moral right to raise animals for food, confine them or turn them into commercial products. Ultimately, he proposes a transformation of society itself, imagining a political community that takes the interests of other living beings seriously.
It is an ambitious, sometimes provocative vision. And not everyone agrees with his reasoning. Even philosophers sympathetic to animal rights have questioned some of his conclusions, especially where he moves from protecting sentient animals to making broader claims about the rights of nature and all living things.
But the book raises an uncomfortable question that remains difficult to dismiss. Our food traditions are full of distinctions that seem perfectly natural until we examine them. We celebrate certain animals, protect others, and turn still others into culinary delicacies. These choices are shaped by geography, religion, memory and culture. They are rarely made from scratch by the individual sitting down to dinner.
Caron's challenge is not that food should cease to be a source of pleasure. It is that pleasure cannot be the only consideration.
A recipe tells us what to do with an ingredient. A culinary tradition tells us why we do it that way. Antispéciste asks an altogether different question:
Who decided that this animal should be an ingredient in the first place?
Sources & further reading
Antispéciste — original publisher excerpt (French) ↗Le Monde — Aymeric Caron and the Republic of Living Beings (2016) ↗Florian Cova & François Jaquet — a philosophical critique (Le Temps, 2016) ↗Inspired by our conversation with Alexis Gauthier. The opening quotation is translated from the French original; this is a cultural introduction, not a full review of the book.
Listen to the conversation with Alexis Gauthier →